How Pedophilia Research Led a University to Part Ways With a Scholar


Allyn Walker predicted the backlash — its chance, if not its extent.

Walker’s ebook, A Lengthy, Darkish Shadow: Minor-Attracted Individuals and Their Pursuit of Dignity, examines adults who’re sexually drawn to youngsters however say they chorus from performing on that attraction. The scholar avoids the time period “pedophiles,” although its literal that means describes solely need, not conduct, partially as a result of it has come to be synonymous within the public thoughts with “little one molester.” In actuality, some, and maybe many, adults who maintain such points of interest haven’t been convicted of molesting minors, in accordance with Walker and different researchers.

“Enable me to be clear: This ebook does not promote sexual contact between adults and minors,” Walker writes within the introduction. Realizing some readers may see it that approach, although, Walker ready. Earlier than the ebook’s publication in June 2021, the scholar, then an assistant professor of sociology and prison justice at Outdated Dominion College, wrote a memo for college leaders with speaking factors to answer that false impression, ought to objections to the analysis come up.

They did.

After a snippet of an interview with Walker went viral, individuals branded Walker, whose pronouns are they/them, as an advocate of kid abuse. College students petitioned to take away Walker from campus. Colin Jost joked on Saturday Evening Stay {that a} professor was “being criticized after saying that it’s not immoral for adults to be sexually drawn to youngsters. Discover out why in his new ebook, Wait! Maintain On! Hear Me Out … ” Tucker Carlson billed Walker as yet one more instance of upper training uncontrolled.

As a torrent of undesirable consideration and threats fell on Outdated Dominion, the college positioned Walker on administrative depart. Lower than two weeks later, Walker resigned. The college depicted the choice as mutual.

In a press release on the time, the president of Outdated Dominion stated it’s a group that “respects educational freedom and stays keen to debate controversial concepts.” Professors on the college query that declare. A few of Walker’s colleagues suppose the establishment ushered the assistant professor out the door. They are saying Outdated Dominion, and particularly the president, deserted a tutorial who research probably the most taboo matters doable. They’ve questioned what would occur if their very own work generated such a hurricane.

“The president and the provost have continued to reiterate that they assist educational freedom. These phrases are crucial,” stated Mona J.E. Danner, chair of Walker’s division. “The actions of the final a number of months don’t assist these phrases.”

Did Outdated Dominion make a tough trade-off between precept and public security? Or did it minimize and run when requested to guard a scholar with controversial concepts?

Walker, who declined The Chronicle’s requests for an interview, didn’t all the time see the topics of their analysis as they do immediately.

They earned a grasp’s diploma in social work from Columbia College in 2010 and spent a 12 months counseling victims of sexual assault and different violent crimes, together with youngsters. Whereas in that job, “when you advised me that in 5 brief years I used to be going to be researching minor-attracted individuals’s experiences with dealing with stigma, I might’ve known as you absurd,” Walker writes. Then they discovered of the existence of adults who’re drawn to youngsters however keep away from any sexual contact.

“I ended assuming that their points of interest meant one thing about their conduct,” Walker writes, “and I started asking questions.”

Questions like how such individuals type identities, how they navigate societal stigma, and the way they’ve averted harming youngsters. A Lengthy, Darkish Shadow, printed by the College of California Press, distills Walker’s interviews with 42 topics and argues that the stigma can hold some individuals from disclosing their points of interest to others, and in the end “propagates the hazard to youngsters that all of us worry.” Walker did a lot of the analysis whereas incomes a Ph.D. in prison justice from the Metropolis School of New York’s John Jay School of Prison Justice and the CUNY Graduate Middle.

Walker’s avoidance of the time period “pedophile” is just not distinctive amongst researchers within the subject. “We’re aware, particularly on this realm, about how we speak about individuals, not wanting to make use of language that’s pejorative, not wanting to make use of language that triggers this concept that this can be a foregone conclusion,” stated Elizabeth J. Letourneau, who directs the Moore Middle for the Prevention of Little one Sexual Abuse on the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg Faculty of Public Well being. Letourneau stated she didn’t know who got here up with the phrase “minor-attracted particular person,” however it’s turning into a typical time period. She makes use of “individuals with sexual attraction to youngsters.” Walker’s work, she stated, is “precisely” the kind of analysis that’s additionally been carried out at Hopkins.

Of their ebook, Walker advocates for treating minor-attracted individuals with empathy. “These are actual human beings who occur to have points of interest that they by no means requested for, that they usually are not looking for, and that they can not eliminate,” Walker writes. That enchantment for compassion may very well be misunderstood, Walker knew. So did Danner, their chair. “One by no means is aware of what may occur, however I simply needed to be ready,” she stated.

So Walker wrote a memo for college officers in Might 2021, addressing that chance. (Particulars of the memo have been first reported by the coed publication Mace & Crown, which additionally raised questions on Walker’s case and educational freedom.)

“Whereas it’s customary for individuals to affiliate points of interest to minors with sexual offending towards youngsters, this ebook explicitly separates these ideas. The ebook does not advocate for the normalization of sexual exercise between adults and minors, and neither do I,” the memo says.

Danner despatched Walker’s memo to Jonathan Leib, interim dean of the School of Arts & Letters. She included a synopsis of Walker’s ebook and credentials and her remark that among the predicted media consideration “could inaccurately painting Dr. Walker’s analysis and assault them” and the college.

On Might 20, 2021, Leib handed alongside the doc to college leaders, together with John R. Broderick, the president, who was stepping down quickly, Austin Agho, the provost, Rhonda L. Harris, then the chief of police, and Giovanna Genard, assistant vice chairman for public relations. Walker’s ebook is a vital addition to current literature on sexual-abuse prevention, Leib wrote. Nevertheless, some individuals may simply learn the title and “misread” the ebook and its targets.

Walker’s ebook is a tutorial textual content and unlikely to obtain a lot publicity, the dean wrote. However “we needed to warn you to the likelihood, simply in case.”

One late afternoon in November, the cellphone rang in Danner’s workplace. The lady from West Virginia on the opposite finish of the road was very upset that an Outdated Dominion professor would “advocate that the sexual abuse of kids was OK,” Danner recalled.

The division chair defined Walker’s work. She and the lady talked for about 20 minutes. On the finish of the dialog, Danner requested the caller, “How do you’re feeling now?” The lady indicated that she felt higher, saying one thing like, “This isn’t what I assumed this was.”

Danner thought-about the dialog a hit. That feeling of triumph shortly subsided.

A pair days earlier, the Prostasia Basis, an advocacy group that claims it helps analysis to forestall little one sexual abuse, printed a half-hour video interview with Walker about their analysis. An internet site known as 4W — an outlet for “immediately’s feminists who’re boldly stepping exterior of the mainstream narrative” — wrote an article in regards to the interview with the headline: “’Non-Binary’ College Teacher Calls to ‘Destigmatize’ Pedophilia,” which bought consideration. Then, a clip of that interview went viral on Twitter.

Within the clip, Walker explains why they use the time period “minor-attracted particular person.” “I’ve positively heard the concept you introduced up, although, that the usage of the time period ‘minor-attracted particular person’ means that it’s OK to be drawn to youngsters,” they are saying. “However utilizing a time period that communicates who somebody is drawn to doesn’t point out something in regards to the morality of that attraction.”

The Twitter account Libs of Tiktok posted the video, writing:


In a thread about Walker, the account wrote, “They’re coming on your children,” and, “He’s actually out right here defending pedos.”

Quickly the college was deluged with complaints, outrage, and threats. Critics disagreed that destigmatizing sexual attraction to youngsters would shield them. Social media ignited with requires Walker’s dismissal, or worse. “Flush em all out into the open by letting them suppose its okay to share your predatory nature, then exterminate all of them. Allyn Walker, you’re within the open and also you’re not onerous to seek out,” one particular person tweeted. A number of the backlash centered on Walker’s transgender id and accused Walker of being a pedophile. When Tucker Carlson lined the story, he referred to Walker as “a self-described ‘nonbinary assistant professor,’” including, “we don’t know what meaning, by the way in which, however that’s what this particular person calls him or herself.” Beside Carlson was a graphic that introduced: “The Left’s Wicked New Low.”


College students at Outdated Dominion additionally objected. They mounted a protest and urged the college to fireside Walker. At ODU, “pedophilia is just not welcomed. And neither is the thought of MAPs,” the protest’s organizer told the Mace & Crown. “There is no such thing as a such factor as a minor-attracted particular person.” At one level, somebody went to the sixth flooring of Walker’s constructing, crossed off their title within the college and employees listing, and scrawled over it, “PEDOPHILE.”

Amid the onslaught, Danner performed protection. She was in frequent contact with college officers and with Walker. She resent Walker’s memo to Genard, the assistant vice chairman for public relations. She sang Walker’s praises to the provost, emphasizing that they have been a extremely productive researcher and beloved instructor.

Initially, she was “thrilled” with the college’s response. Two days after the clip of Walker’s interview began making the rounds, the college issued a press release quoting Walker’s protection of their analysis and supporting free inquiry: A tutorial group “performs a priceless function within the quest for information.” Meaning “being keen to contemplate scientific and different empirical information which will contain controversial points and views,” it read.

Danner’s sense was that “this was a storm that we have been going to climate collectively.”

Then the forecast shifted.

On November 16, Walker taught two courses in particular person, with two campus law enforcement officials stationed exterior the classroom door, in accordance with Danner, who accompanied Walker to these courses. The periods went nicely. Walker learn a brief assertion initially of every class and noticed some “nods” from college students, the assistant professor advised Danner through e mail. Attendance was regular, and college students have been engaged. Walker was “optimistic for my future courses the remainder of this semester,” they wrote.

Danner handed alongside Walker’s evaluation to the provost, writing, “In brief, it’s not true that each one college students are towards or frightened of Dr. Walker, and lots of college students are snug with Dr. Walker as their professor.”

However that day, in accordance with Danner, Walker was known as to a gathering with a number of senior directors, together with September Sanderlin, the college’s vice chairman for human sources. On the assembly, Walker was repeatedly requested what they needed to do, and every time responded by saying they needed to remain at Outdated Dominion and educate, in accordance with Danner, who spoke with Walker straight after the assembly.

After every reply, Walker was requested one thing like, “What could be the following smartest thing?” or “What else would you want?” in accordance with a abstract of what Walker advised Danner, which Danner later emailed to the College Senate’s govt committee. Walker “repeatedly tried to find out whether or not there was any path ahead for them at ODU within the VP’s minds, which admin wouldn’t reply straight; ODU admin frequently pressed Dr. Walker to contemplate going to a different college or pursuing one other ‘alternative,’” Danner wrote. (Sanderlin didn’t reply to a request for remark.)

In the course of the assembly, Walker was positioned on indefinite administrative depart. They left with the impression that they most likely didn’t have a future at Outdated Dominion. They known as Danner, who rushed over to satisfy them. One other college member, Ruth Triplett, a professor of sociology and prison justice, picked the pair up and drove Walker residence.

Walker was “in an emotional state,” Triplett advised The Chronicle, “and Mona and I have been each in an emotional state as a result of nobody anticipated that they’d be positioned on administrative depart.”

Walker’s depart discover, obtained by The Chronicle, stated that the motion was being taken “resulting from considerations over your security and that of the campus, and to handle the fast results of the response to your analysis and ebook which has impacted the College’s mission of instructing and studying.”

Brian O. Hemphill, Outdated Dominion’s new president, reiterated that concern for security when he defined Walker’s depart in a message to campus. “Ideally, we might have the ability to debate even probably the most difficult points with out disruption or threats of violence, however that’s not the world we stay in immediately,” Hemphill stated. “Our campus has not too long ago turn out to be the goal of threats and different unacceptable disruption.”

Old Dominion University President Brian O. Hemphill.

Outdated Dominion College

President Brian O. Hemphill of Outdated Dominion U.

Hemphill additionally touched on the subject material of Walker’s analysis. “Many people have shared with me the view that the phrase ‘minor-attracted individuals’ is inappropriate and shouldn’t be utilized as a euphemism for conduct that’s unlawful, morally unacceptable, and profoundly damaging,” Hemphill stated. “It is very important name pedophilia what it’s.

As a father,” the president continued, “I’m troubled by this narrative and its potential penalties for my youngsters and that of future generations.”

“Analysis into delicate matters and the expression of recent or controversial views lie on the coronary heart of educational analysis. … On the identical time,” Hemphill wrote, “this freedom carries with it the duty to talk and write with care and precision, notably on a topic that has induced ache in so many lives.”

That assertion signaled to Danner, and to at the least a number of different college members, that the college was publicly shifting its assist away from Walker. The president’s phrases threw Walker “below the bus,” Amanda M. Petersen, an assistant professor in Walker’s division, advised The Chronicle. “There’s a component of victim-blaming right here. … Like, if Allyn hadn’t spoken about their analysis, or hadn’t spoken about their analysis in a approach that some individuals didn’t like, that this all wouldn’t have occurred.” Hemphill was utilizing the identical rhetorical framework as those that have been misconstruing Walker’s analysis, professors observed: lumping adults who commit sexual offenses towards youngsters, and people who chorus from doing so, into the identical group.

The individuals Walker research haven’t finished something unlawful, or morally unacceptable and profoundly damaging, Triplett stated, “except you suppose simply ideas are morally unacceptable and profoundly damaging.”

Hemphill insists he was misunderstood. In an e mail to The Chronicle, he wrote that his assertion “was in regards to the narrative” round pedophilia, “particularly the conduct, not Dr. Walker or their analysis.” The college “has not and won’t” criticize Walker’s analysis, he wrote. “In my messages to campus round this matter, I addressed the problem of civil discourse typically by underscoring an inclusive and supportive group particularly,” the president stated. “My phrases clearly known as for compassion, concern, and assist for all and by all.”

Two days later, on November 18, Triplett drove Walker to a different assembly with senior directors. In the course of the experience, Walker reiterated to Triplett that they needed to proceed working on the college, she stated in an e mail. However on the assembly, Walker was “once more requested at the least twice what else, aside from remaining at ODU, they needed, and every time Dr. Walker replied that they needed to stay at ODU,” Danner later relayed to the chief committee.

On the identical time, Danner met with Hemphill and advised the president that Walker needed to remain. In line with Danner, Hemphill replied that that would not occur. He stated the college would assist Walker depart the establishment, she later advised the committee.

When requested about that assembly, Hemphill advised The Chronicle that it will “not be applicable for the College to publicly talk about a personnel matter, together with a dialog with an worker’s supervisor.”

By that time, Walker had retained attorneys by the Basis for Particular person Rights in Training. Six days later, on November 24, Walker and the college jointly announced that the assistant professor had “determined to step down.” Walker thanked Outdated Dominion, the division of public security, their colleagues, college students, FIRE, and Danner.

In a message to college, employees, and college students, Hemphill ended a abstract of the previous two weeks on a optimistic be aware. “The overwhelming majority of Monarchs engaged in civil discourse, even these amongst us for whom private expertise made the topic of kid sexual abuse particularly painful,” the president stated.

“We protected freedom of speech. We rejected violence. And, we took the required steps to guard life and security — a prerequisite to the train of the tutorial and different freedoms we cherish.”

Once the attorneys bought concerned, neither Danner nor Triplett have been aware of what was being mentioned between the 2 events, they stated. Walker’s resignation announcement got here as a blow. Of their earlier conversations, “I by no means bought any sense that they needed to do the rest however be right here, educate their college students … and proceed the work that they’re doing,” Triplett advised The Chronicle. Petersen stated the identical to the Mace & Crown. When she and Walker spoke on November 19, Walker “desperately needed to remain at ODU.”

Justin Dillon, a accomplice at KaiserDillon PLLC, which represented Walker, advised The Chronicle in an e mail that he was “glad we have been in a position to work with ODU to resolve this case in a mutually agreeable method” however didn’t elaborate on what the decision entailed. “I wish to suppose that the college discovered some priceless classes about free speech within the course of,” Dillon stated.

After Walker resigned, it turned “actually clear that Dr. Walker can’t speak, or is just not going to talk, about numerous issues,” Danner stated. However “I’m nonetheless grieving.”

Danner thinks the college pressured Walker’s hand. Given, amongst different issues, the executive depart, the repeated questions on what options to staying they want, and the pace of the method, “in no case can Dr. Walker’s resignation be thought-about to be freely made,” Danner wrote to college senators. (Requested by The Chronicle to touch upon that perspective, Hemphill pointed to the joint assertion saying Walker’s resignation.)

The chief committee reviewed Walker’s case by interviewing individuals concerned and located, amongst different issues, that Outdated Dominion had not correctly adopted its personal administrative-leave coverage and may have supplied Walker college illustration at conferences with directors.

“I don’t suppose the college was ready to cope with what occurred,” Triplett stated. There was a rush to get the story out of the media, she stated, and sadly, Walker was seen as the issue.

Within the months since, professors at Outdated Dominion have pressed the administration for readability about Walker’s resignation, for acknowledgment that Walker’s analysis is effective, and for some recognition that a lot of the hatred directed at Walker needed to do with their being transgender.

Although the wave of reactions was mighty, leaders at Outdated Dominion may have finished extra “to withstand the ability of the misreading of Dr. Walker’s work” and to guard the scholar’s popularity within the establishment’s messaging, the college’s chapter of the American Affiliation of College Professors wrote in an open letter. Outdated Dominion’s response “primarily indicated that if a battle emerges between educational freedom and hateful political teams that threaten violence, then the politics of hate will win,” Kent Sandstrom, a professor in Walker’s division and a former dean of the faculty, stated in an e mail. “I can’t consider a extra troubling precedent.”

Hemphill has reiterated to involved professors that the college is dedicated to educational freedom, and that the executive depart was meant to maintain each the campus and Walker secure. “It was finished out of an immense quantity of care and concern,” the president advised The Chronicle in an e mail. Hemphill stated that the college’s police division reviewed “roughly 3,000 threats” associated to the Walker controversy, and that “many” have been discovered to be credible. “Such threats included bodily hurt and even demise,” Hemphill stated. “For our College, this was all the time a security situation and by no means a problem of educational freedom or free speech.”

For Hemphill, the query of campus security could really feel particularly pressing. The president labored because the vice chairman for pupil affairs and enrollment administration at Northern Illinois University in 2008, when a campus shooter opened fireplace, killing 5 college students. Hemphill co-edited a 2010 ebook, Sufficient is Sufficient: A Scholar Affairs Perspective on Preparedness and Response to a Campus Taking pictures, which delves into the aftermath of each the Northern Illinois and the Virginia Tech shootings.

“We respect the truth that he cares for campus security, and we do genuinely consider that,” stated Dan Richards, president of the college’s AAUP chapter. “We simply felt like, on this particular case, they made a misstep by going proper to administrative depart.”

Richards additionally recommended Hemphill and the provost for being open with and listening to college members within the aftermath of Walker’s resignation. Nonetheless, some college members stay frightened about how the establishment will react the following time a scholar attracts undesirable consideration.

“We now have not been given robust sufficient proof from the administration that this gained’t occur once more if any of our analysis have been to get this stage of assault or outrage on-line,” stated Ruth Osorio, an assistant professor of English and ladies’s research. When requested, the president has stated that the overwhelming majority of school members don’t conduct analysis that’s as controversial as Walker’s. “And my query is all the time, nicely, what about that 1 %?

Walker’s Outdated Dominion contract ends this month. In the intervening time, at the least, they’ve discovered a tutorial residence. They’ll be a postdoctoral fellow at Johns Hopkins’s Moore Middle for the Prevention of Little one Sexual Abuse.

It seems that Walker has not spoken on the file about what occurred to any information outlet since they resigned. Within the midst of the firestorm, they gave an interview to the web journal Jezebel, and sounded optimistic.

“I believe my experience is effective to ODU and actually enhances its very strong criminal-justice program,” Walker says within the article, printed on November 19, 5 days earlier than they introduced they have been stepping down.

“My analysis positions ODU to be on the forefront of creating efficient methods to forestall little one sexual abuse,” they stated. “Once more, my ebook doesn’t advocate for the normalization of sexual exercise between adults and minors, and neither do I below any circumstances, ever.

So yeah, I’m hopeful that that might be understood.”


Leave a Comment